The History of DMEM/F-12

1 Introduction

The influence of cell culture technology on human society has been immeasurable. Progress in biology in recent years, for example, has depended heavily on cell culture technology.1 In addition, cell culture-based practical technologies have been developed in various areas, including the assessment of the efficacy and toxicity of new drugs, manufacture of vaccines and biopharmaceuticals, and assisted reproductive technology. As the reprogramming of somatic cells became technically feasible recently, researchers around the world are fiercely competing for leadership in the advances of regenerative medicine. In this area likewise, cell culture technology is regarded as a foundation for further development and popularization.

No one probably would argue against the claim that a culture medium is the most important factor in cell culture technology. A medium supports cell survival and proliferation, as well as cellular functions, meaning that the quality of the medium directly affects the research results, the biopharmaceutical production rate, and treatment outcomes of assisted reproductive technology. It is essential, therefore, for investigators who are working with cell cultures to select an appropriate medium that is suitable for their aims. In some cases, researchers should modify a medium themselves. In addition, when facing problems, researchers have to know the properties of the medium in order to identify the cause of any problem with their experiments.

At present, synthetic media can be classified into several groups, based on the type of supplements added; for example, serum-containing media, serum-free media, protein-free media, and chemically defined media (Tables 1 and 2). Serum-containing media naturally contain various serum-derived substances, which make the medium composition unclear and whose concentrations can fluctuate from batch to batch. This situation makes the culture results less reproducible and poses a risk of microbial contamination. Serum-containing media, however, can be designed easily and be used effectively for a variety of cell types because serum includes a lot of active substances that are necessary for the survival and growth of animal cells.2 Serum-free media, in contrast, have a defined composition, resulting in a high reproducibility of results, and the cultivation process can be validated. In addition, target cells can be grown selectively in an intermingled cell population if the culture conditions are configured to benefit them. Among the serum-free media, subgroups of protein-free media (which do not contain any protein at all) and chemically defined media (which do not contain any undefined ingredient) provide additional stability and reproducibility for culture systems, facilitating the identification of the cellular secretions and reducing the risk of microbial contamination. However, the serum-free media are difficult to design: only specific cell types have been cultivated this way to date.3

Table 1.
Categories of animal-cell culture media
Category Definition Type Example
Natural media Consisting of natural biological substances, such as plasma, serum, and embryo extract Coagulant or clots Plasma separated from heparinized blood, serum, and fibrinogen
Tissue extracts Extracts of chicken embryos, liver, and spleen and bone marrow extract
Biological fluids Plasma, serum, lymph, amniotic fluid, and pleural fluid
Synthetic media Composed of a basal medium and supplements, such as serum, growth factors, and hormones Serum-containing media Human, bovine, equine, or other serum is used as a supplement
Serum-free media Crude protein fractions, such as bovine serum albumin or α- or β-globulin, are used as supplements
Xeno-free media Human-source components, such as human serum albumin, are used as supplements but animal components are not allowed as supplements
Protein-free media Undefined components, such as peptide fractions (protein hydrolysates) are used as supplements
Chemically defined media Undefined components, such as crude protein fractions, hydrolysates, and tissue extracts, are not appropriate as supplements, but highly purified components, such as recombinant proteins are appropriate supplements
Table 2.
Types and characteristics of basal media
Category Name (author, year) Features
Connaught Medical Research Laboratories (CMRL) media Medium 199 (Morgan et al. 1950) Developed in order to cultivate chicken embryonic cells under protein-free conditions, it is prepared by the sequential addition of amino acids, vitamins (including fat-soluble vitamins), and nucleic-acid precursors. Its composition is extremely complex because the components that are thought to be necessary on theoretical grounds, including inactive components, are added to the medium. Often used for organ culture
CMRL1066 (Parker et al. 1957) Created by amending Medium 199 in order to culture mouse L cells under protein-free conditions, the modifications included increased levels of reducing substances (cysteine, glutathione, and ascorbic acid), the elimination of fat-soluble vitamins, changes in the types of nucleic-acid precursors, and the addition of coenzymes
Eagle media Basal medium Eagle (BME) (Eagle 1955) Supplemented with the minimal components that are necessary for mouse L cells and human HeLa cells to reach the index of proliferative capacity and including 13 amino acids and eight vitamins, it is unsuitable for cells whose cultures require many components because of its simple composition
Minimum essential medium (MEM) (Eagle 1959) BME modified according to the cellular need for amino acids, so the concentrations of the majority of amino acids are twofold, as compared to BME. Non-essential amino acids, which cells can biosynthesize, were not included in the original MEM formulation; however, researchers can add non-essential amino acids to reduce the biosynthetic load
Dulbecco’s modified MEM (DMEM) (Dulbecco and Freeman 1959) Modified to have fourfold the concentrations of amino acids and vitamins that are present in BME and developed to study the plaque-forming ability of the polyoma virus in mouse embryonic cells. Various modifications have been made since, with supplementation, for example, of the non-essential amino acids, glycine and serine, iron, and pyruvate. The glucose concentration also can be increased to 25 mmol L−1 in order to accommodate cells with high nutritional requirements. In the event that pH changes are suspected due to metabolites, sodium bicarbonate is doubled in concentration, equilibrated, and then used at 10% CO2
α-MEM (Stanners et al. 1971) MEM modified for hybrid-cell-line research on mice and hamsters, its composition is MEM supplemented with non-essential amino acids and vitamins (ascorbic acid, biotin, and cyanocobalamin), pyruvate, lipoic acid, and nucleosides
Iscove’s modified DMEM (IMDM) (Iscove and Melchers 1978) Supplemented with several non-essential amino acids and vitamins that are not present in DMEM (cyanocobalamin and biotin) and additional selenite, pyruvate, and HEPES. Transferrin, bovine serum albumin, and soybean lipids are added as serum substitutes. With its high concentrations of amino acids and vitamins, IMDM is suitable for high-density cultures and cultures of rapidly proliferating cells
Tissue Culture Section of the National Cancer Institute (NCTC) media NCTC109 (McQuilkin et al. 1957) Developed to culture L cells under protein-free conditions, its amino acid composition is based on the results of a componential analysis of the compounds that have been ultrafiltered from horse serum and chicken embryonic-tissue extract. Its composition is quite complex, with not only coenzymes, nucleobases, and reducing agents, but a wealth of vitamins added, as well (ie, A, C, D, E, and K, in addition to the B-group vitamins). Cysteine was included in the original composition, but after it was found to negatively affect cells, a version was developed from which cysteine was removed (NCTC135)
Ham media Ham’s F-10 (Ham 1963) Enables colony formation by a single Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell under serum-free conditions, developed by adding two kinds of purified serum proteins (serum albumin and fetuin), instead of serum, and by examining in detail the types and concentrations of amino acids and trace elements This medium was the first to contain the trace elements, copper and zinc (iron having been included in other media already). The CHO cells have an inferior proliferative capacity in this medium alone, compared to the one with serum added. Furthermore, culture of the cell lines other than CHO necessitates the addition of serum
Ham’s F-12 (Ham 1965) The serum albumin and fetuin (used in Ham’s F-10) are replaced by two compounds with definite chemical composition: linoleic acid and putrescine, which enables colony formation by a single CHO cell under protein-free conditions. Often cited as the world’s first chemically defined medium, the levels of several amino acids are higher than in Ham’s F-10, while those of the vitamins (except choline and inositol) and potassium phosphate are reduced. Its composition must be modified (eg, by reducing the zinc concentration) for a protein-free culture of cells other than CHO cells. MCDB301, in which 20 trace elements were added, was later developed after it became obvious that trace elements contaminating water or raw materials are necessary for a protein-free culture of CHO cells in Ham’s F-12.
Kaighn’s modified Ham’s F-12 (Ham’s F-12K) (Kaighn 1974) The concentrations of the amino acids, pyruvate, biotin, calcium, magnesium, putrescine, and phenol red are increased with respect to those in Ham’s F-12, among other compositional modifications, in order to support the proliferation and differentiation of primary cultured cells
Roswell Park Memorial Institute (RPMI) media RPMI 1640 (Moore et al. 1966) Based on the 5A Medium (developed by McCoy et al. 1959) and modified for the long-term culture of peripheral blood lymphocytes, it is characterized by low levels of calcium and magnesium and high levels of phosphate. Multiple media were developed on the path to this medium (eg, RPMI 1629, 1630, and 1634). It is widely used as a medium for suspension cultures; for example, of white blood cells, lymphocytes, and hybridomas
Molecular, Cellular, and Development Biology (MCDB) media For example, MCDB202 (McKeehan et al. 1976)

MCDB301 (Hamilton et al. 1977)

MCDB153 (Peehl et al. 1980)

MCDB110 (Bettger et al. 1981)

MCDB402 (Shipley et al. 1983)

MCDB170 (Hammond et al. 1984)

MCDB131 (Knedler et al. 1987)

A series of Ham’s F-12-based media that was developed in order to grow specific cell types in serum-free culture. The composition of each MCDB medium is optimized to promote the growth of a specific cell type. In particular, MCDB202 is a medium for the serum-free culture of chicken embryo fibroblasts; MCDB301 is for the serum-free culture of CHO cells; MCDB153 is for human keratinocytes; MCDB110 is for human fibroblasts; MCDB402 is for mouse fibroblasts; MCDB170 is for the mammary epithelium; and MCDB131 is a medium for the serum-free culture of human vascular endothelial cells
Mixed media DMEM/F-12 (Barnes and Sato 1979) Constitutes a 50:50 mixture of component-rich Ham’s F12 medium and the nutrient-rich DMEM medium and compatible with the requirements of a variety of cell types, it is most often used as a basal medium for serum-free culture
RPMI 1640/DMEM/F-12 (RDF) (Murakami 1984) Developed for the serum-free culture of hybridomas, it is a mixture of RPMI 1640, DMEM, and Ham’s F-12 at 2:1:1 and is typically used as a serum-free medium with added insulin, transferrin, ethanolamine, and selenite
Other media Waymouth’s MB752/1 (Waymouth 1959) Developed with as simple a composition as feasible, so that mouse L929 cells could be cultured without the addition of serum and other proteins, it is composed of a total of 40 components, including glucose, inorganic salts, amino acids, vitamins, purine bases, and hypoxanthine. It is characterized by high concentrations of glucose, histidine, lysine, glutamine, choline, and thiamine
Trowell’s T-8 (Trowell 1959) Designed for the long-term culture of adult rat liver epithelial cells. With its comparatively simple composition, it contains no non-essential amino acid and hardly any vitamins, but is characterized by high glucose and insulin concentrations. It is used for short-term organ culture
Leibovitz’s L-15 (Leibovitz 1963) The buffering capacity is mediated by phosphates and free basic amino acids instead of sodium bicarbonate, so that a culture’s pH is maintained in ambient air without the use of a CO2 incubator. Instead of glucose, pyruvate (and galactose) is added at a high concentration in order to control pH drops due to the lactic acid that is produced during glucose metabolism and to promote the release of CO2 from the respiratory chain. Another major characteristic is that each of its constituent amino acids is added at approximately its respective maximal concentration. Once used for cell and tissue transport and primary cultures, its popularity has declined as researchers began to use HEPES as a buffering agent and as they realized, moreover, that a certain amount of sodium bicarbonate is necessary for optimal cell proliferation
Fischer’s Medium (Fischer and Sartorelli 1964) Contains a high concentration of folate because this medium was developed by using folate-dependent L5178Y lymphoma cells
  • HEPES, 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid.

At present, formulations of popular media for cell culture are available commercially. Thus, there are investigators who are using culture media without understanding their details and background, particularly regarding the rationale for their development, the exact ingredients, as well as the cell types that these media are suitable for. This review article briefly describes the history of the development of animal-cell culture media, with comments on the types of media in general use today regarding their characteristics, roles of the medium components, and pitfalls or problems with their use.

Shopping Cart